Skip to main content

Employee Navigator alternatives for quoting and proposals

Searches for an Employee Navigator alternative usually mean one of two different things, and it matters which. Employee Navigator is a benefits administration and enrollment platform — 195,000+ employers, 7,000+ brokers, onboarding, HR, ACA reporting and payroll integrations — and Planlined is not an alternative to that. Its quoting, though, comes from a marketplace integration with Zywave CPQ, which quotes from a rates database and exports to PowerPoint or Excel. If the step you want to replace is that one — turning the carrier quotes you were actually sent into a comparison, a contribution model and a proposal — then the five tools below are the alternatives, and all of them sit alongside whatever enrollment platform you keep.

Updated September 5, 2026|8 min read• By

Which step are you replacing?

Enrollment and administration is one product category; the proposal that wins the group is another. Employee Navigator, and Ease before it, live in the first. Ease itself is being retired into Employee Navigator — no new companies from January 1, 2027, read-only from July 1, 2027 — which is why many brokers are re-evaluating their stack now. If your question is where to enroll groups, the honest answer is that Employee Navigator is Ease's designated successor and this article will not help you choose a different one. If your question is how to get from a stack of carrier PDFs to a client-ready proposal without a rates database or a bundled Zywave contract, read on.

Planlined

Planlined parses carrier PDFs and spreadsheets — quotes, SBCs, rate sheets and invoices — with no cap on documents per case, into a side-by-side comparison across unlimited carriers, contribution modeling with five or more structures and a scenario manager, invoice reconciliation, and branded proposal-book and employee-guide exports. It does not run enrollment, so it pairs with Employee Navigator rather than replacing it. Pricing is published: the first proposal is free with no card, then $75 a month or $62 a month billed annually, with Enterprise custom. See the full Planlined vs Employee Navigator comparison, and the Planlined vs Ease page if your groups are on Ease.

QuoteMap

QuoteMap uploads up to eight carrier PDFs or spreadsheets per case, extracts 26 fields per plan, applies employer contribution per tier, and produces proposals and benefit guides. It suits small and mid-size brokerages on per-seat pricing. Pricing is published: $100, $200 and $350 per seat a month, with three free runs to start. See the Planlined vs QuoteMap comparison.

PerfectQuote

PerfectQuote combines RFP workflows to carriers with a Proposal Reader that parses carrier proposals and SBCs across 400+ formats. It publishes pricing on a two-year agreement — $141, $217 and $272 per user a month, two-user minimum — with no free trial and four to five weeks of onboarding. It suits brokers and general agents with heavy RFP volume who want a specialist quoting platform next to their ben-admin system. See the Planlined vs PerfectQuote comparison.

Plansight

Plansight reads carrier proposals in whatever format they arrive, normalizes them into side-by-side comparisons, builds presentations and offers unlimited scenario modeling. It is sold to mid-size and large brokerages through a sales process and does not publish pricing. It suits national firms that want an enterprise contract for the proposal step. See the Planlined vs Plansight comparison.

BenSuite

BenSuite is the one option here that covers both categories: an all-in-one broker platform with CRM, quoting, renewals, commissions and enrollment, where BenBuilder AI turns an uploaded carrier quote PDF into a side-by-side spreadsheet. If you want to replace the enrollment platform and the quoting step in one move, it is the candidate on this list. Pricing is published: $99 per agency user a month, or $84 a month billed annually, with a 30-day free trial. See the Planlined vs BenSuite comparison.

How to choose

  • Keep enrollment where it is. Unless you are consolidating onto BenSuite, none of these replace Employee Navigator for enrollment. Choose the proposal tool on its own merits and let sold plans flow into ben-admin as they do today.
  • Where your quotes come from. If your book already runs through Zywave CPQ's rates database and you are happy with it, the integration is the path of least resistance. If your quotes arrive as carrier-issued PDFs and spreadsheets, a document-first tool matches the work.
  • How you want to buy. Planlined ($75 flat), QuoteMap (from $100 per seat) and BenSuite ($99 per agency user) publish prices and start self-serve. PerfectQuote publishes a price on a two-year term. Plansight is negotiated.

Related Content